Driving vs Driving: Doing it on autopilot
Taking my driving test all over again – in my thirties – really got me thinking about the way we humans learn, and the way we perform tasks. With particular reference to golf.
For those who don’t know, one of the things I’ve been working on since throwing in the muddy golf towel is obtaining a truck driving licence. This plan all comes to a head this Thursday, when I take my test in the bus-infested, multi-hazard hell that is London.
Yes, this is still a golf blog…and I’ll get to the golf connection in a minute. Go with me.
So, anyone who drives a car will remember what it was like trying to learn. Doing everything consciously, having to think about where the gears are, reminding yourself to use the clutch, all that stalling. It was hideous, wasn’t it? But now, of course, you can pretty much drive in your sleep. You’ve almost certainly experienced arriving at work and remembering nothing about your journey. I know I have.
This doesn’t actually seem all that remarkable until you go for lessons in a completely different vehicle 15 years later. You have a head start in some respects – like knowing how to use a clutch – but you’re suddenly you’re dealing with a gear-change system that involves continuous switching from high to low range ratios. And, sure as anything, you’re fiddling and fumbling like a fiddling, fumbling thing. Unsightly and ungainly as Jim Furyk, but minus the accurate results.
It’s like time travel. You’re a goofy 17-year-old all over again, hacking away at the lever, instructor rolling his eyes and saying his prayers.
It’s having this experience AFTER you’ve done the driving-on-autopilot thing that really opens your eyes to how amazing our learning ability is. You’re getting a reminder of where you began. And you know that in time (please, God, before Thursday), you’ll be on autopilot in this vehicle too. But it’s still ever so hard to believe while you’re in this state of total cluelessness.
What’s especially remarkable is that just about all able-bodied humans seem able to go quickly from anarchic novice to doing everything automatically. It’s not just talented, clever people who can do it. Just try talking mathematical integrations down at your local truck stop if you don’t believe me. My point is that, like a child picking up language, we seem to be wired with a learning ability for this particular task.
Now, why can’t it be that easy for a golfer? On the face of it, dealing with ever-changing traffic conditions, an ever-changing rev count, ever-changing speed, unpredictable drivers, pedestrians and animals is a pretty complex task that should demand more attention than hitting a stationary ball to a stationary target with plenty of constant information to help you do so. Particularly given that death or serious injury is a risk on the road, not the golf course. Yet it’s the car, and not the golf ball, that we can drive without any fear of failure.
When we read coaching manuals or talk to coaches, especially the mind coaches, we are told that we should be trying to golf on a similarly automatic level. No matter how much work we do at the range, we should go onto autopilot when we’re over the ball.
Of course, most of us golfers cannot do this. Evidence would suggest that it’s one of the hardest things in the world to get right. And even if you do manage to slide into automatic mode on the golf course (as I did from time to time), the results can still be the equivalent of a nine-car pile-up with multiple fatalities.
Interesting, isn’t it? Is golf the odd task out, or is it driving? Well, learning to cycle seems to follow a similar pattern to learning to drive. At first you think it’s impossible, and fall on your face all day. And then, one magic moment, it clicks. And you never give technique a thought for the rest of your life. Same goes for learning how to type on a keyboard, teaching yourself the control buttons for your favourite PlayStation game, even reading for heaven’s sake! Slow, clumsy and entirely conscious going at first – and then suddenly you’ve got it forever. Even swimming is the same: some people may be scared to learn, but I don’t think it changes the fact that we all have a natural ability to swim – once we pass through that drunken-octopus learning phase.
Golf is never like this for anyone, except maybe some gifted pros. And even that is doubtful. Would Luke Donald or Rory McIlroy compare hitting a wedge to the middle of a green 120 metres away to riding a bicycle? Can they have entirely the same certainty of success? They could do it with their eyes closed, so maybe you can argue they do. But even if it’s true for them, we’re talking a tiny fraction of humankind – there’s little evidence that widespread hardwired golf learning ability exists for regular people.
Golf is quite unique amongst ball sports because there are no team-mates or opponents complicating what is a fundamentally pure task. Which is why, if you’d landed from Mars, you’d think it might be like balancing on a bike or hooking third gear with literally no thought.
But it’s not. I’m about to disappoint you with my conclusion, I think. Golf is a rotten old son of a so-and-so. Dangit! There you go. Now tell me what I’ve forgotten – let’s get some discussion going below!










